Its never an easy job to get yourself to decide what works and what doesn’t. So here I am figuring which broker would suit me best for trading. As usual, all of us would have a similar wish list;
- high intraday margin
- low comms/discount
- good and cheap data
- good execution
- no platform freezing
From the above, one could forget abt getting these offers from any SIngapore brokerage, I can’t believe MFGlobal sg charge me $12 per round turn! Thats daylight robbery. So this is my new list of possible brokers,
Interactive Brokers
World reknowned discount brokerage, unbelieavably low commisions, fairly okay data but bad platform. TWS sucks, but one thing to note is that their data is compatible with Ninjatrader, which has one of the best excution platform to date, oh did i tell you that HSI futures are also tradeable though IB. IB will definitely one of the top choices, provided i get to integrate Ninjatrader with it.
TradeStation
Well she’s the mammoth when it comes to providing charting solutions & data vendoring, from that, they have now took a further stepp forward to become a competitive discount broker, which rivals IB in terms of commision and product range. Yet as a broker, their reliability and new platform has come under much scrutiny. I’ve heard complains about bad fills, freezing platforms etc. I’m gonna be very careful in selecting them now, but nevertheless, these guys used to be the market leader and to me tradestation platform is still very very desirable.
Mirus Futures & AMP Futures
These two brokers came under my radars only recently, well they don’t offer stocks trading but what sets them apart is the data and platform that they are offering, not forgetting the cheap comms (not as cheap as IB but i’ll explain why). Data using Zen-fire;
Here are a few of the advantages of the Zen-Fire solution:
- Redundancy & Reliability: co-located on the data center floor with the exchanges
and over 18 major Internet providers on a fully redundant network managed by a leading IT service provider
- Always-On-Technology: no more ‘end of day’ processing down-time; the system
is available whenever there is an exchange open for trading.
- Global Network: connect to exchanges around the world on the same
reliable network
- Open API: automate your systems directly to the API
- Speed and Unfiltered Data: receive every market update at unprecedented speed
- Alternative Connectivity Options : connect using the Internet, directly to
the data center or have your systems hosted on-site
- Advanced Risk Management and Order Entry Features: built in features that allow risk managers and order desks to quickly and efficiently manage accounts, liquidate positions and enter orders
- Excess Capacity: the system is constantly monitored and easily expandable to accommodate massive amounts of users and products
- Option Trading: access to trade all electronic options on futures
If thats not good enough, they offer ninjatrader as a trading platform FREE! OMG! I’ve always loved NT’s Dynamic Superdom and their order management controls, they have gone a long way to improve their charts too. I would suggest one to demo with NT to find out more on the pearls that this team of trading solution provider is offering. NT is the real deal guys and you get it free by trading with Mirus and AMP. The charges for this platform have already been factored into comms. You have the choice to use Dorman or Rosenthal Collins Group as your clearing party. Definitely TOP in my shopping list now!
MB Trading
Well i have a soft spot with them coz they are essentially the broker is use to trade fx. While I believe that their commissions for FX should be revised to rival brokers like dukas and IB, nevertheless they offered one of the best data feeds and allows you to trade in between spreads. Thats totally cool. They have a futures platform which runs on navigator, a platform that I am very familiar with and have data compatible with Ninjatrader but you only get to use the simulated version, so no superdoms and all those magic, just charts and a tabbed style navigator (sucks!). They trade through Penson. Hmmm and their comms for stocks trading, is fairly okay, feedbacks suggest that MBT is not suitable for the average day trader.
So now, its time to call each and everyone of them…lets see who is more enthusiastic to offer me their services. I’m after all a potential client…lol.